Listing Board: Key West Association

As is Rght to Inspct: Yes

Species List: Yes

Current Price: $3,299,000

Listing Date: 2026-06-13

List Price: $3,299,000

City: Sugarloaf

Off Shore Island: No

Mile Marker: 17

Marathon Neighborhood: N/A

Side: Ocean

Flood Zone: AE,AE

Alternate Key #: 1210633

Parcel #: 00165130-000000

Zoning: IS - Improved Subivision District

Deed Restrictions: Unknown

Legal: LT 121 SUGARLOAF SHORES SEC D SUGARLOAF KEY PB4-88

Taxes: 5105.72

Tax Year: 2025

Pub Sewer HkUp: Yes

Street #: 17042

Direction: W

Street Name: Starfish

Street Suffix: Lane

Key/Island: Sugarloaf Key

State/Province: FL

Zip Code: 33042

County: Monroe

Subdivision: Sugarloaf Shores (17.0)

Area: 06 - Bay Point to Sugarloaf

Realtor.COM Type: Residential - Single Family

Waterfront: Yes

Control Depth: 3

Lot SqFt: 12500

Pool: No

Lot Sqft Source: Property Data Card

Total Units: 0

Acres: 0.29

SqFt Source: Property Data Card

Rentals Allowed: With Restrictions

Min Rental Days: 28

Style: Single Family

Year Built: 1982

Living Apx SqFt: 3700

Total Bedrooms: 6

Full Baths: 4

Half Baths: 1

Total Baths: 5

Remarks – Consumer: Set among lush tropical landscaping and located just one home in from open water, this completely reimagined Sugarloaf Key residence blends refined coastal design with the space, comfort, and functionality buyers seek in the Florida Keys. Thoughtfully transformed through a complete renovation, the property is now a polished 6-bedroom, 4.5-bath retreat with open-water views, generous living areas, an elevator, and the feel of a private resort. Inside, engineered hardwood floors, impact windows and doors, and a bright, open layout create a warm coastal atmosphere. The chef's kitchen features stainless steel ZLINE appliances, ample workspace, and an easy connection to the dining and living areas, making the home equally suited for relaxed everyday living and effortless entertaining. The spacious primary suite is a private oasis, complete with a walk-in closet, custom tiled dual shower, and private balcony overlooking the turquoise waters of Sugarloaf Sound. Five additional well-appointed bedrooms and beautifully finished guest baths provide comfort and privacy for family, guests, office space, or extended stays. Outside, the property truly feels like a private resort. A new pool, expansive entertaining areas, tiki hut, and tropical landscaping create an inviting setting for sun-filled afternoons, outdoor dining, and evenings by the water. The layout offers multiple spaces to gather, unwind, and enjoy the natural beauty of the surroundings. Open-water views enhance the setting, while the private boat ramp and quick water access make fishing, diving, and island adventures effortless. Additional features include a 3-car garage, large enclosure for storage and flexible use, plus all-new HVAC, plumbing, and electrical systems. With its comprehensive renovation, resort-style outdoor living, and exceptional Sugarloaf Key location, this residence offers a rare combination of luxury, function, and effortless island living.

Directions: From Overseas Hwy, turn oceanside onto Sugarloaf Blvd. Starfish W is 6th road on Right. 17042 is next to last house on left.

Mandatory Home Owners Asc: No

Voluntary Home Owners Asc: Yes

1st Right of Refusal: No

Association Fee $: 0

None: 1

Dock Length: 100

Dock: Concrete

Boat Ramp: 1

Fixed Bridge Height: 10

Seawall: Concrete

None: 1

Dishwasher: 1

Gas Appliances: 1

Microwave: 1

Oven: 1

Range: 1

Refrigerator: 1

Stainless Steel Appliance(s): 1

Pets Allowed: 1

Ceiling Fans(s): 1

Central Air: 1

Canal Front: 1

Bay/Gulf View: 1

Canal View: 1

Open Water View: 1

Tile: 1

Wood: 1

Bike Paths: 1

Elevator: 1

Entrance Foyer: 1

Split Bedroom: 1

Walk-in Closet(s): 1

Updated/Remodeled: 1

Above Flood: Yes

Stilt Column Height: Medium - 5Ft - 9Ft

Impact Rstnce Doors: 1

Impact Rstnce Window: 1

Car(s): 4+

Covered Parking: 1

Garage: 1

Guest Parking: 1

Open Parking: 1

RV Parking Open: 1

Attached: 1

Off Street Parking: 1

Trailer Storage: 1

Combo Construction: 1

Frame: 1

Hardi Board Siding: 1

1/4 - 1/2 Acre: 1

Unfurnished: 1

Cash: 1

Conventional: 1

FHA: 1

VA: 1

Buyer to Verify: 1

FKAA: 1

Municipal Sewer: 1

Propane: 1

Negotiable: 1

Chickee Hut: 1

Fencing: 1

Storage: 1

Metal Roof: 1

Contingent: Contingent/Show

Status: Contingent/Show